How UK asylum system creates perfect conditions for modern slavery and exploitation to thrive

What’s the value of cultural awareness?

Our research aims to provide reliable data on the link between systematic oppression and the risks of modern slavery in the UK

Project summary

The Challenge

Systematic oppression affects various groups and makes them vulnerable to exploitation, rendering response to modern slavery ineffective.

The Approach

We spoke directly to relevant statutory and non-statutory organisations, as well as adult survivors of modern slavery across four regions in England.

The Outcome

Our research shows the value of cultural awareness in preventing modern slavery risks.

Lead academics

Funded by

Project partners

The Challenge

Modern slavery and labour exploitation are ongoing issues within the UK. The nature of these offences mean that the scale of the issue is hard to estimate but in 2022, 16,938 potential victims of modern slavery in the UK were referred to the Home Office.

The systemic oppression of individuals belonging to various sociodemographic groups, such as those of a particular race, class, or sexuality, leads to an increase in their vulnerability to exploitation and makes modern slavery responses ineffective.

To date, there has not been enough targeted research on interventions relating to the different vulnerabilities and structural factors underpinning modern slavery. Specifically, there has been no previous research to determine the cultural understanding or 'competency' of modern slavery responses in the UK, and how effective they are in mitigating risks. 

The full research team

The Approach

This project seeks to generate an assessment of the value of cultural competency and practices in improving equity and effectiveness in legal enforcement, support services and identification of those affected by modern slavery.

Our research aimed to provide reliable data on the link between systematic oppression and the risks of modern slavery in the UK. We also examined the importance of cultural competency in preventing such risks and safeguarding those who are vulnerable to them.

An overview of the project methodology

This project focused on individuals facing discrimination based on protected characteristics; it analyses how cultural competency can address modern slavery and re-exploitation risks by answering the following research questions: 

  • To what extent can engagement and delivery of services to individuals be improved based on their cultural background and identity? 
  • What are the cultural and identity barriers for people with lived experience of modern slavery to engage with the necessary professionals and organisations? How can these be managed/mitigated? 

The research team conducted four case studies in different geographical areas: a coastal region, a metropolitan region, a rural region and an area consisting of a dense metropolitan centre surrounded by agricultural land and rural communities. For primary data collection, we created a list of related first responders, charities, and statutory and non-statutory organisations in each case study area to be invited for interviews and/or focus group discussions.

The West Midlands Anti-Slavery Network, Humber Modern Slavery Partnership, and the North Wales Police and Crime Commissioner helped the team distribute the research to the modern slavery workforce and promote it at related conferences and events. This helped us achieve a broad sample of 36 participants from the list to ensure responses could be generalised sufficiently and give representative results.

Interviews and focus groups were semi-structured, wherein short lists of questions related to the issue were designed to guide discussions with research participants. Four individuals with lived experience of modern slavery also participated in our research through interviews and a focus group.

The team found that current UK policies concerning modern slavery and immigration can have a significant impact on the provision of support for victims of modern slavery. Professionals working in this area have to navigate through a challenging landscape of new legislation. For many professionals working in this area, survivors always come first ... however, the new policies could limit their ability to do so. Dr Zahra Shirgholami, Project Lead

The Impact

The team has finalised the report and it will be published soon.

The findings presented barriers for the potential victims of modern slavery and survivors to access support created by a lack of cultural and structural competency at micro/individual-, meso/organisation- and macro/policy and legislation levels. We have identified barriers at these levels, particularly for those who may face discrimination based on protected characteristics: age, disability, gender assignment, marriage and civil partnership, pregnancy and maternity, race, sex, and sexual orientation. The research found that culturally and structurally competent approaches to service delivery are most effective when barriers at all three levels are recognised and addressed.

The team also held a workshop to disseminate and discuss the findings of the research to practitioners in Birmingham in February 2024.

Top